Squarespace vs Custom Website in 2025: A Real Before & After
"Our Squarespace site looks fine. Why would we pay for custom?" That's what our client said. Six months later, they're ranking on page one and getting 3x the leads. Here's exactly what we changed—and why it mattered.
I'm not here to trash Squarespace. It's a solid tool. For many businesses, it's enough. But for this client—a B2B industrial supplier—Squarespace was a ceiling they didn't know they'd hit.
Let me show you what "good enough" was costing them, and what changed when we rebuilt from scratch.
The Client: BuyGeogrid.com
BuyGeogrid sells geosynthetic products to contractors and engineers across Ohio. Not a flashy business. Not a viral product. Just a solid B2B company that needed their website to generate leads and build trust.
Their Squarespace site looked... fine. Professional enough. But they weren't showing up in Google for their target keywords. Their pages loaded slowly. And they couldn't build the custom features they needed without breaking Squarespace's templates.
Before & After: Homepage
What Changed:
- • Clear value proposition – Visitors immediately know what the company does
- • Faster load time – From 4+ seconds to under 2 seconds
- • Strategic CTAs – Every section guides visitors toward contact
- • Mobile-first design – 60% of their traffic is mobile
Before & After: Product Pages
Squarespace's templates forced everything into the same layout. The new site has 28+ pages, each optimized for specific products and search terms. That's 28 opportunities to rank in Google—instead of fighting for attention on a generic "Products" page.
The Real Difference: What You Can't See
Screenshots are nice. But the biggest improvements weren't visual:
Squarespace Limitations
- • Generic templates, same as competitors
- • Slow page loads (4+ seconds)
- • Limited SEO control
- • Can't add custom features
- • Bloated code you don't need
- • Locked into their ecosystem
Custom Development
- • Unique design, built for your business
- • Fast loads (under 2 seconds)
- • Full SEO optimization per page
- • Any feature you need
- • Clean, efficient code
- • You own everything
New Features They Couldn't Build on Squarespace
Custom video integration with schema markup. Interactive project galleries with lightbox. Registration forms that actually work. None of this was possible within Squarespace's constraints.
Should You Leave Squarespace?
Honestly? Probably not. For most small businesses, Squarespace is fine. Here's when it's worth the upgrade:
Consider Custom Development If:
- 1. SEO matters to your business – You need to rank for specific keywords, not just "look professional"
- 2. You've hit template limits – You need features Squarespace can't do
- 3. Speed is costing you conversions – Slow sites = lost customers
- 4. You're in a competitive market – When everyone uses templates, custom stands out
- 5. You want to own your site – Not rent it from a platform
The Bottom Line
Squarespace is a tool. Custom development is an investment. Both have their place.
For BuyGeogrid, the investment paid off. They went from invisible to page one. From "looks fine" to "looks like the leader in their space." From a template to a custom machine built for their exact needs.
Is your website a ceiling or a launchpad? That's the real question.
Wondering If You've Outgrown Your Website Builder?
We'll take a look at your current site and tell you honestly whether it's holding you back—or doing the job. Free, no pressure.
Get a Free Site Review